A Rocky Start for Rookie Quarterback Will Howard

Despite being selected in the sixth round of the 2025 NFL Draft from Ohio State, where he contributed to a national championship team, Will Howard has struggled to adapt to NFL-level competition. His preseason performance—a 58% completion rate with two interceptions—has raised doubts about his readiness to lead the Steelers. Scouts have criticized his decision-making under pressure, highlighted by a 27th-ranked "under-pressure" grade among draft-eligible quarterbacks prior to the season . While his physical attributes (a strong arm and mobility) are acknowledged, critics argue he lacks the composure needed to succeed against NFL defenses.

The Aaron Rodgers Factor

Speculation surrounding Green Bay Packers veteran Aaron Rodgers continues to overshadow the Steelers' quarterback plans. Rodgers' ambiguous statements—such as his "you never know" remark during a recent Q&A—have kept fans and analysts speculating about a potential move. Steelers president Art Rooney II has expressed patience but admitted time is limited, with mandatory minicamp approaching on June 10. A Rodgers signing could instantly elevate Pittsburgh to playoff contention, but his unresolved personal commitments delay a decision.

Backup Options and Strategic Crossroads

If Rodgers remains unsigned, the Steelers face a critical choice: fully commit to Howard's development or lean on veteran backup Mason Rudolph. Rudolph's uninspiring preseason performance (including a 53% completion rate) offers little assurance. Meanwhile, head coach Mike Tomlin insists the team is "not in a rebuilding phase," emphasizing the need for immediate success despite the QB uncertainty.

Broader Context and Implications

This Quarterback controversy has eclipsed other significant offseason moves, including the trade for star receiver DK Metcalf and the departure of former starters Russell Wilson and Justin Fields. Analysts like Dan Orlovsky warn that a poor start under Howard or Rudolph could lead to a disastrous 0-6 record, underscoring the urgency of resolving the QB situation.

Conclusion: A Season Defining Decision

The Steelers' 2025 Season hinges on whether Howard can rapidly improve or Rodgers commits before key roster deadlines. With Week 1 against the New York Jets looming, the team's gamble on youth—or potential veteran infusion—will determine both short-term success and long-term credibility.