The Quarterback Conundrum

As the 2025 NFL Season approaches, the Pittsburgh Steelers face a critical decision at the quarterback position. Ben Roethlisberger, the franchise’s legendary signal-caller, recently warned that the team’s success hinges on Aaron Rodgers’ willingness to join. On his Footbahlin podcast, Roethlisberger projected a dismal 7-10 record without Rodgers, ending the team’s 21-year streak of non-losing seasons. With Rodgers on board, he envisions an 11-6 campaign, crediting the four-time MVP’s ability to tilt close games—like a potential Week 3 showdown against the New England Patriots.

Rodgers’ Potential Impact

Fit vs. Legacy

Rodgers, 41, represents a short-term fix for a position that has struggled since Roethlisberger’s retirement in 2021. Kenny Pickett, Russell Wilson, and Justin Fields all failed to stabilize the role. However, Rodgers’ mobility—a concern given his age and the team’s shaky offensive line—could complicate matters. Roethlisberger noted that Wilson, despite better athleticism, was overwhelmed by sacks in 2024 (100 for Wilson, 99 for Fields). The Steelers’ line ranked 28th in pass-blocking efficiency last season, raising doubts about Rodgers’ viability.

Front Office Stance

Steelers president Art Rooney II confirmed ongoing talks with Rodgers but stressed a deadline. With $40M in cap space, Pittsburgh could accommodate Rodgers’ $10M/year demand. While scheduling quirks—like facing the Jets (his former team) in Week 1 and Packers (his old squad) in Week 8—add drama, Roethlisberger dismissed the NFL’s claim that this influenced negotiations.

Skepticism and Alternatives

Hall of Famer Terry Bradshaw criticized the pursuit as a “one-year band-aid,” arguing the team should trust Pickett, a Super Bowl winner with the Eagles. Analyst Dan Orlovsky echoed concerns about the roster’s quality and whether Rodgers would truly elevate the team.

Plan B?

If Rodgers declines, the Steelers’ options grow thin. Backup Mason Rudolph (10-12 career record) and rookie Will Howard (inconsistent college stats) offer little hope. Coach Mike Tomlin admitted they lack a signed QB, leaving the door open for other veterans.

The Gamble

Rodgers’ 2024 stats (3,600 yards, 28 TDs, 10 INTs) hint at potential, but durability is a risk after back-to-back injury-plagued seasons. His presence would boost a passing attack ranked 26th last year, especially with DK Metcalf now on offense. For the Steelers, this is a race against time: Rodgers could extend their window to compete in a stacked AFC North while stars like T.J. Watt and Cam Heyward remain.

Roethlisberger’s Verdict

“You don’t want to waste the prime of your defense chasing a rebuild,” Roethlisberger concluded. The clock is ticking—for Rodgers to decide, and for Pittsburgh to capitalize on its championship window.