The Quarterback Crossroads

The Pittsburgh Steelers face a critical decision in their pursuit of a reliable quarterback as the 2025 NFL offseason progresses. With Aaron Rodgers’ future still uncertain and his potential move to Pittsburgh in limbo, the team is exploring contingency plans targeting veterans like Carson Wentz and Kirk Cousins to fortify their roster.

The Aaron Rodgers Conundrum

Rodgers, a four-time MVP, remains a central focus for the Steelers. Despite visiting the team’s facility and being linked to them since Free Agency began, his indecision has kept the franchise in wait. Released by the Jets in March 2025, Rodgers has yet to sign with any team as of late May. His reported interest in the New York Giants and Minnesota Vikings complicates matters further, as he seeks a contender with young talent to mentor.

Why the Delay Matters

Rodgers’ prolonged uncertainty leaves the Steelers in a precarious position. His potential $23.5M annual cap hit could be manageable given the team’s projected $55M in Salary Cap space, but restructuring his contract may be necessary to free immediate funds. Pittsburgh’s current quarterback room—featuring Mason Rudolph, Will Howard, and Skylar Thompson—lacks proven starting experience, heightening the urgency for a solution.

Backup Plans: Carson Wentz and Kirk Cousins

Carson Wentz

The 33-year-old former Pro Bowler, now a free agent after a year with the Chiefs, offers veteran Stability. With a career that includes a Super Bowl win, Wentz could serve as a reliable backup or short-term starter. Steelers insider Ed Bouchette noted he might help the team “muddle through” 2025 while rebuilding for the future. However, competition for Wentz includes the Saints and Cardinals.

Kirk Cousins

At 36, Cousins seeks a fresh start after falling out of favor with the Falcons. Benchmed in favor of rookie Michael Penix Jr., he could be traded if Atlanta accepts partial compensation for his remaining $84M contract. The Steelers’ cap flexibility ($40M+ available) makes absorbing his $40M cap hit feasible, though negotiations would require collaboration with the Falcons.

Financial Flexibility and Strategic Priorities

Pittsburgh’s $55M projected cap space gives them leverage. Releasing players like Preston Smith or extending T.J. Watt’s deal could free additional funds. Signing Rodgers or Cousins would address immediate needs while aligning with the team’s AFC North ambitions. Both veterans would complement weapons like DK Metcalf and Jaylen Warren in an offense needing leadership.

Coach Tomlin’s Approach

Head coach Mike Tomlin has emphasized evaluating “all options” in free agency and the draft. The Steelers’ urgency stems from avoiding another season of quarterback uncertainty. Delaying a decision risks losing top targets to other teams, as Cousins’ trade market and Wentz’s free agency could heat up post-draft.

Conclusion: Stability is Key

Whether through Rodgers, Wentz, or Cousins, the Steelers must secure a proven quarterback to pair with their strong defense and compete in the AFC North. Time is of the essence—resolving the quarterback crisis will determine their 2025 success.