The New York Mets, seeking roster flexibility and offensive depth, are exploring a trade to replace underperforming outfielder Starling Marte with former Yankees powerhouse Giancarlo Stanton, according to MLB sources and recent trade rumors. This move could boost the team’s power output, align with their 2025 playoff goals, and shed Marte’s remaining contract obligations.

Why Trading Starling Marte Makes Sense

At 36, Marte has struggled since signing a four-year, $78 million deal in 2022. His 2024 performance (.715 OPS) and declining defense (-13 defensive runs saved over two seasons) have made him a financial burden. With $19.5 million still owed in 2025, the Mets reportedly plan to cover part of his salary to facilitate a trade. With stars like Juan Soto and Brandon Nimmo dominating the outfield, Marte’s role has dwindled to part-time duty, making him a viable trade chip.

Giancarlo Stanton: A Powerhouse Addition

At 34, Stanton—released by the Yankees during their 2025 rebuild—brings a proven track record of power, with a career .261/.343/.540 slash line and over 450 home runs. Though sidelined by elbow issues early this season, he’s nearing a return by late May. His ability to DH full-time could free Soto to focus on right field, addressing both offensive and positional needs. The Yankees, prioritizing youth, might seek prospects or salary relief in exchange, making a swap plausible if the Mets absorb part of Stanton’s $29M annual salary.

Risks and Rewards for the Mets

Acquiring Stanton addresses two priorities: replacing Marte’s production and optimizing the DH role. His left-handed power would balance the lineup, while his clutch hitting could elevate run production. Trading Marte would also free up $10–$15M in payroll, allowing reinvestment in bullpen upgrades or extensions for core players like Pete Alonso. However, Stanton’s durability remains a concern, and his limited defensive versatility could strain outfield depth if Soto shifts positions. Developing prospects like Drew Gilbert in the minors may offset these risks.

Conclusion: A Calculated Gamble

A Marte-to-Yankees-for-Stanton deal could be a win-win. The Mets gain immediate power and financial flexibility, while the Yankees clear cap space for rebuilding. Despite Stanton’s injury history, his potential resurgence and the timing of the Yankees’ rebuild create a unique opportunity. As the 2025 trade deadline nears, this move could solidify the Mets’ status as NL East contenders—if they’re willing to take the risk.