The Cleveland Browns’ 2025 offseason has been defined by uncertainty at the quarterback position, with recent developments suggesting rookie Dillon Gabriel’s future with the team is in jeopardy despite being selected in the third round of April’s NFL Draft. Here’s an analysis of the challenges threatening his tenure in Cleveland.

The Quarterback Logjam

The Browns’ decision to draft Shedeur Sanders in the fifth round has intensified competition for playing time. With Joe Flacco and Kenny Pickett as established veterans, and Deshaun Watson sidelined by a re-ruptured Achilles tendon, Gabriel faces a crowded roster. This five-quarterback race has placed him in a high-stakes battle where early mistakes—like a tipped interception during OTAs—could prove costly. Insider criticism, including a “zero percent NFL readiness” remark from team reporter Zac Johnson, underscores the uphill battle ahead.

College Success vs. NFL Reality

Gabriel’s standout college career at Oregon—a 72.9% completion rate, 3,857 passing yards, and 30 touchdowns in 2024—contrasts with NFL concerns about his 5-foot-11 frame and lack of prototypical size. Comparisons to undersized quarterbacks who struggled professionally loom large. Meanwhile, Sanders has gained early favor with coaches due to his stronger arm and higher draft projection.

The Watson Factor

Watson’s recurring Achilles injuries and $92 million guaranteed salary complicate the Browns’ plans. While Flacco and Pickett serve as stopgaps, the team hopes a rookie will emerge as a long-term solution. Gabriel’s slow start in OTAs and Sanders’ momentum have shifted focus, raising the possibility of a midseason roster move.

What’s Next for Gabriel?

The next few months are critical. To survive, Gabriel must excel in coach Tommy Rees’ run-heavy scheme, dominate preseason matchups, and silence critics. His confidence—“It’s love” for Cleveland—must translate to consistent performance. Failure to outpace Sanders could lead to a familiar Browns strategy: cutting underperforming rookies to make room for prospects.

Conclusion

Gabriel’s fate hinges on his ability to adapt to NFL demands and outperform rivals in training camp. With Watson’s future uncertain and the Browns prioritizing Stability, the window for the Oregon product to prove himself is narrowing.

Keywords: Cleveland Browns, Dillon Gabriel, quarterback competition, Shedeur Sanders, NFL draft strategy