The Rookie Holdout

The Cincinnati Bengals face an unexpected challenge as first-round draft pick Shemar Stewart, the 17th overall selection in the NFLDraft-0.html target=_blank class=infotextkey>2025 NFL Draft, remains unsigned ahead of organized team activities. The Texas A&M defensive end skipped rookie minicamp drills over concerns about training camp roster bonuses in his proposed contract, marking a rare rookie holdout in the salary-capped NFL era.

Contract Structure Dispute

At issue is the percentage allocation for future roster bonuses, which reportedly falls short of what the 17th overall pick received in the 2024 draft. Stewart’s representatives argue this violates the unwritten rule of year-over-year contract progression for draft slots. The Bengals’ front office maintains their offer complies with NFL rookie wage scale parameters while preserving salary cap flexibility.

Organizational Pattern Emerges

This standoff continues a troubling trend for Cincinnati. Pro Bowl receiver Ja’Marr Chase publicly criticized his contract talks in 2023, while defensive stalwart Trey Hendrickson’s extension remains unresolved. Team executives face growing scrutiny for prioritizing financial maneuvering over relationship-building with cornerstone players.

Strategic Implications

Stewart’s absence carries immediate consequences:

• Delayed installation in defensive coordinator Lou Anarumo’s system
• Missed reps with projected starting defensive line
• Potential erosion of fan excitement for the new draft class

Salary Cap Realities

With quarterback Joe Burrow’s $275 million contract consuming 16.2% of the 2025 cap, Cincinnati’s $24 million in remaining space must address multiple needs. However, league sources confirm restructuring veteran contracts could create $8-12 million in additional flexibility without cutting core players.

League-Wide Ramifications

Agents across the NFL monitor this negotiation closely. A favorable resolution for Stewart could establish new benchmarks for bonus structures in future rookie deals, particularly for mid-first round selections. Conversely, a protracted holdout might encourage teams to take harder stances in similar negotiations.

Path to Resolution

Both sides face mounting pressure as OTAs approach:

• Stewart risks falling behind in defensive scheme mastery
• Bengals need pass-rush help after ranking 25th in sacks last season
• NFL’s collective bargaining agreement limits negotiation points, pushing parties toward compromise

Broader Labor Context

This standoff reflects evolving player empowerment in the NFL. Rookies increasingly leverage their draft position to secure favorable terms, while teams balance short-term roster needs against long-term financial health. The outcome could influence how franchises approach negotiations with high draft picks in the 2026 class and beyond.