Yankees’ Giancardo Stanton Decision - Injury Comeback Analysis
Rehabilitation Progress and Team Strategy
The New York Yankees organization faces its most significant roster decision of 2025 as power hitter Giancarlo Stanton completes recovery from bilateral elbow tendonitis. The 35-year-old designated hitter becomes eligible for activation on May 27, forcing the team to weigh his potential contributions against recurring injury risks.
Recovery Timeline Update
Stanton's rehabilitation reached a crucial phase this week with successful live batting practice sessions. Manager Aaron Boone confirmed the slugger is now running bases at full capacity, marking the final stage of his physical recovery program. Medical staff continues monitoring his elbow response to increased throwing and hitting workloads.
Current Team Performance Context
Despite Stanton's season-long absence, the Yankees lead Major League Baseball in three key offensive categories:
- .287 team batting average (1st in MLB)
- 89 home runs through 45 games
- .912 on-base-plus-slugging percentage
The current DH rotation featuring Ben Rice and Aaron Judge has produced exceptional results, creating complex lineup decisions for management.
Contract Considerations and Risk Factors
Several critical elements complicate Stanton's return:
- $32 million annual salary through 2028
- History of 7 DL stints since 2019
- Previous season's playoff performance (ALCS .407 BA)
- Current elbow stabilization without surgery
Medical Team's Cautious Approach
Yankees head physician Dr. Christopher Ahmad emphasized the unique challenges of bilateral tendonitis recovery: "This injury requires careful load management. We're tracking daily iNFLammation markers and swing mechanics data before clearing game action."
Key Decision Factors
Front office executives will evaluate three primary elements before May 27:
- Bat speed metrics compared to 2024 levels
- Defensive flexibility in right field
- Minor league Rehab Assignment performance